Carboot Sale vs eBay vs Vinted
Which is the best way to sell your stuff? An honest comparison.
You've decided to sell your unwanted stuff — but should you haul it to a car boot sale, list it on eBay, or photograph it for Vinted? The honest answer is: it depends on what you're selling. Each platform has genuine strengths and real drawbacks.
This guide gives you a straight comparison with no agenda. We'll cover fees, time investment, what sells best where, and the hybrid approach that smart sellers use to maximise their earnings across all three.
Quick Comparison
| Factor | Carboot | eBay | Vinted |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fees | £8-15 flat | 12.8% + 30p per order | 0% (buyer pays) |
| Average Earning Per Item | £1-5 | £5-30 | £5-20 |
| Time Per Item | Seconds (it's on the table) | 15-30 minutes | 5-15 minutes |
| Payment Speed | Instant (cash) | 2-5 working days | 2-5 days after delivery |
| Audience | Local only | National / Global | National |
| Shipping Needed | No | Yes | Yes |
| Best Season | Spring - Autumn | Year-round | Year-round |
| Returns / Disputes | None (all sales final) | Yes (buyer protection) | Yes (buyer protection) |
Platform Deep Dive
A closer look at each platform with honest pros and cons.
🚗Carboot Sale
Fees
£8-15 pitch fee
One flat fee for your pitch. No percentage taken from sales. You keep every penny you make after the pitch fee.
Time Investment
4-6 hours (one day)
Including loading the car, driving there, setting up, selling, packing up, and driving home. It's a whole morning, but everything happens in one go.
Earning Potential
£50-200 per sale
Depends on what you're selling and the size of the sale. Most sellers with a car boot full of decent items make £80-150.
Pros
- +Cash in hand — no waiting for payments
- +No posting, packaging, or shipping hassle
- +Clear everything in one go — books, clothes, kitchenware, toys, the lot
- +No fees on individual items (just the pitch fee)
- +Social and fun — it's a day out, not a chore
- +Bulk and heavy items sell easily (furniture, tools, equipment)
Cons
- -Weather dependent (outdoor sales can be rained off)
- -Early starts — you'll be up at 5:30am
- -You'll need a car and the ability to transport everything
- -Limited to local buyers (smaller audience)
- -Items sell for less than they would online (bargain culture)
- -Unsold items come home with you
Best for: Bulk clearouts, heavy items, mixed lots, kitchenware, books, children's items, and anything that's not worth the effort of posting individually.
🛒eBay
Fees
12.8% + 30p per order
eBay takes 12.8% of the total sale price (including postage) plus 30p per transaction. On a £20 sale with £3.50 postage, that's £3.31 in fees.
Time Investment
15-30 mins per item
Photographing, writing descriptions, listing, then packaging and posting when sold. Multiply by 50 items and it's a significant time commitment.
Earning Potential
Higher per item
Items typically sell for 2-5x more on eBay than at a boot sale because you're reaching a national (or global) audience of targeted buyers.
Pros
- +Huge audience — millions of active buyers in the UK alone
- +Best for collectibles, rare items, and niche products
- +Auction format can drive prices up for sought-after items
- +Managed payments mean reliable payouts
- +You can sell 24/7 — listings work while you sleep
- +Detailed sold price data helps you price accurately
Cons
- -12.8% + 30p fees eat into profits
- -Time-consuming to list, package, and post each item
- -Returns and buyer disputes can be stressful
- -Postage costs for heavy items can make sales uneconomical
- -Items can take weeks or months to sell
- -Platform changes and policy updates can be frustrating
Best for: Collectibles, electronics, branded goods, rare items, vintage pieces, and anything niche where specialist buyers exist.
👗Vinted
Fees
0% seller fees
Vinted charges the buyer a service fee, not the seller. You receive the full sale price. This makes it significantly cheaper than eBay for sellers.
Time Investment
5-15 mins per item
Listing is quick — snap a few photos, write a brief description, set a price. Vinted generates shipping labels automatically. Less effort per item than eBay.
Earning Potential
Good for fashion
Clothing, shoes, and accessories sell well. Average sale prices tend to be £5-25 per item, but branded and designer pieces go for more.
Pros
- +Zero seller fees — you keep everything
- +Very quick and easy to list items
- +Built-in shipping labels (no trips to the post office with your own labels)
- +Strong buyer base for fashion, especially among younger shoppers
- +Bump feature helps promote your listings
- +Clean, simple interface compared to eBay
Cons
- -Primarily fashion-focused — not great for non-clothing items
- -Lower average sale prices than eBay
- -Payment held until buyer confirms receipt
- -Buyers expect very low prices and heavily negotiate
- -No auction format — fixed price only
- -Less suitable for collectibles, electronics, or homeware
Best for: Clothing, shoes, handbags, accessories, children's wear, and sportswear. Especially good for branded fashion from the high street and above.
What Sells Best Where?
This is the most important section. Matching items to the right platform is how you maximise your returns.
| Item | Best Platform | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Branded trainers (Nike, Adidas) | Vinted | Fashion-focused audience willing to pay for brands |
| Children's clothing bundles | Carboot | Parents love browse-and-buy; posting bundles is expensive |
| Retro video games | eBay | Collectors search specifically; auction can drive up rare titles |
| Kitchenware & crockery | Carboot | Heavy, fragile, expensive to post; people want to see condition |
| Designer handbags | eBay | Widest audience of buyers willing to pay premium prices |
| Books (general fiction) | Carboot | Worth 50p each — not worth the postage and listing effort |
| High street dresses | Vinted | Quick to list, no fees, fashion-aware buyers |
| Power tools | Carboot | Heavy, awkward to post, buyers want to check they work |
| Vinyl records | eBay | Discogs cross-listing works well; collectors pay fair prices |
| Furniture | Carboot / FB Marketplace | Impossible to post; needs local buyer with a big car |
| Vintage jewellery | eBay | Global collector market; hallmarks and rarity drive value |
| Baby equipment (prams, cots) | Carboot / FB Marketplace | Bulky items that parents want to inspect in person |
⏱️Earning Per Hour: A Rough Comparison
Time is money. Here's how the platforms compare when you factor in the actual hours spent.
Carboot Sale
Earn £100 in 5 hours = £20/hr
Includes setup and pack-up time. Higher if you have quality stock.
eBay
Earn £200 from 30 items at 20 mins each = £20/hr
After fees and postage. Can be higher for valuable items, lower for cheap ones.
Vinted
Earn £150 from 20 items at 10 mins each = £45/hr
No fees helps. But limited to fashion items; results vary widely.
These are rough averages. Actual results vary hugely based on what you're selling, your pricing, and your experience level.
The Hybrid Approach (Recommended)
Smart sellers don't choose one platform — they use all three strategically. Here's the system that maximises your total earnings while minimising effort.
📋1. Sort Everything First
Go through all your items and create three piles: 'sell online' (valuable, branded, collectible, easy to post), 'sell at boot sale' (bulk items, heavy things, low-value items), and 'charity shop' (damaged, very low value, or unsaleable).
💻2. List Valuable Items Online First
In the 1-2 weeks before your boot sale, list your higher-value items on eBay or Vinted. Branded clothing, electronics, collectibles, and anything worth £10+ usually sells for more online than at a boot sale. This gives them time to sell before the boot sale.
🚗3. Take Everything Else to the Carboot Sale
All the items that are too bulky to post, too low-value to list individually, or didn't sell online go to the boot sale. Books, kitchenware, ornaments, kids' toys, DVDs — all the things that would take forever to list online but sell easily in person for £1-3 each.
🏷️4. Use the Carboot Sale as Your Final Clearout
Price to sell. Your goal at the boot sale isn't to maximise per-item profit (that's what online is for) — it's to clear everything in one go. Bundle deals, low prices, and a 'fill a bag for £1' offer in the last hour will shift remaining stock.
♻️5. Donate or Recycle the Rest
Whatever doesn't sell at the boot sale goes straight to a charity shop or textile recycling on the way home. Don't take it back into the house — it'll sit there for another year.
📅Seasonal Factors
The time of year should influence your platform choice:
- Spring/Summer: Peak car boot season. Use boot sales for your main clearout while the weather is good and buyer numbers are high.
- Autumn: Boot sales wind down. Shift to online selling. This is also a great time to list Christmas-relevant items on eBay.
- Winter: Online only (unless you find an indoor boot sale). Vinted picks up as people look for fashion bargains. eBay gift-buying peaks in November/December.
- January: Vinted booms as people sell unwanted Christmas gifts and do New Year clearouts. eBay is quieter until late January.
Ready to sell? Find a boot sale for your in-person items, or start listing online today.
Know a car boot sale that's not listed?
Help us build the most comprehensive car boot sale directory in the UK. Add a sale and help others discover great local events.